You’ve done it – the piece of writing you’ve honed and worked on has got to the point where you want some feedback. Woo hoo. Well done. Snoopy dance!
This piece of writing is your baby, you’ve crafted it and you’ve imagined it.
You’ve enjoyed it enough to think about sharing it with the Surbiton Writers Group in one of our writers circles.
Reticent about receiving feedback on your writing
But you are stalling with the next bit – thinking about what that feedback is going to be like.
Something says: “I’m not sure if I want to”, “what if they don’t like it,” or even “Nooooo. I’m not ready yet. “
So – should you be nervous of hearing about what we think and should you take our advice on board anyway..?
Evaluating writing subjectively and objectively
Writing is an art and as such, is evaluated subjectively and objectively.
The subjective experience of people’s writing is what’s personal and unique to each reader, what you think and feel while you are reading it and afterwards.
Often private and not shared, it stays in your thoughts and memory, with snippets coming back to you over time. It’s the: “I really enjoyed that book,” feeling, without necessarily explaining to yourself and others why.
The objective experience of someone’s writing is like a critique – what we do in the Surbiton Writers Group. It involves standing back from the piece of writing. This says: “I really enjoyed that book,” but you do explain why.
Here, you focus on, for instance, the way the writing was constructed throughout the entire piece, the way the dialogue was written, how it felt on an emotional level or the way the grammar and punctuation read throughout.
As we also look at writing for online publication, we talk about constructing blog posts properly, for instance.
We are also interested in author marketing, by the use of social media and sharing work, so that’s included too.
Both the subjective and objective experience of the piece of writing is used in the SWG.
What’s included in a writing critique – constructive feedback is key
People critique in different ways, but, in the Surbiton Writers Group, we focus on giving constructive feedback.
As we say on our website’s front page, constructive feedback pinpoints elements of the piece of writing in a way that is in itself positive.
It is positive because it explains if, why and where elements of the piece of writing needs more work and also where the writing was successful.
We discuss and suggest and explain this with the writer in our circle sessions.
It’s not a cold process, it’s intended to be interactive, discursive and helpful.
The objective is to give the writer feedback that they can utilise and work on. It is never, ever to make the writer feel bad, or say their work is worthless.
We critique and give feedback about the writing, not the writer.
Why critique writing anyway?
You are right – no pun intended – writers can skip this step. However the Surbiton Writers Group is interested in helping develop people’s writing to achieve their aims.
Some SWG members simply want immediate and quick feedback, full stop. However other SWG members also intend to publish their writing at a later stage by approaching publishers, submitting to competitions or pitching for writing online.
It’s best to know the strengths and weaknesses in your writing before you get to that stage.
Publishers and editors are inundated by manuscripts and submissions. Yours has to be the best it can be, before it’s seen by others.
Audience, author branding and marketing is part of that too.
Consider us your market research!
Constructive criticism guidelines – the ‘how to’ of giving feedback
That’s why we are doing it, but what do we do?
One of our members has an MA in Creative Writing, where there were weekly peer critiques about the students’ work.
She developed a useful set of criteria which is very helpful when thinking through what you want to say.
Here’s her list of what to consider. Our thanks to Alex for these:
Form, voice, theme, plot and structure and pacing, details, language and tone, style, characterisation, dialogue, setting and place.
We also consider:
Sub-editing – like spelling, grammar and punctuation.
Form and format – like writing format for online or book manuscripts.
Ways of developing your audience – maximising your marketing potential to build an audience for your writing
How do you know what advice to take on board?
Although there are many different viewpoints in the writers circle we advise that if you find a piece of feedback is being repeated by group members or resonates strongly with the group members, that’s the feedback to focus on and pay attention to.
Think of it like market research. If a lot of people say the same thing, that’s something that shouldn’t be ignored.
Diversity of writers within the Surbiton Writers Group
The diversity of writing interests in the SWG is crucial to giving a breadth of feedback.
We are not only fiction-writers, we have non-fiction writers, playwrights, journalists, children’s authors, bloggers and people that like writing but aren’t currently producing anything too.
All of us have different tastes, perspectives and professional or educational backgrounds.
There are different ages and stages in life in our group also.
All of this brilliant diversity makes for really interesting, creative, well rounded constructive feedback to take away and help you successfully polish and finish your piece of work.
Copyright The Surbiton Writers Group 2016
We are open to new members from all types of writing backgrounds. If you are interested in joining the Surbiton Writers Group, email us on email@example.com and we’ll get back to you.